Government Motors
reality
Somewhat to my surprise, the Obama administration took a hard line with the U.A.W. and effectively warned it not to push its luck. So far, the U.A.W. has resisted making any significant concessions, but if the administration keeps this up it might just have no alternative but to do so.
Obama, a soi-disant left-winger and friend of labor unions, is willing to step on the U.A.W., while kow-towing to the powerful bankers, letting them keep their outrageous taxpayer-funded compensation packages after a few cosmetic paybacks. This shows the truth behind the Atlantic article about the financial oligarchs. Not that the U.A.W., doesn’t need stepping on, quite the contrary, but the bankers have done far more to ruin their industry and the economy than the U.A.W. ever has.
Of course, the last bastion of the labor unions is the public purse. In my opinion, there would be little wrong with labor unions in the private sector if their Sherman Act anti-trust exemption were to be repealed, and something like the European co-determination model adopted. But the strike power has no place in the public sector, where the government monopoly gives the unions control over essential services. And of course they have abused this disproportionate advantage, holding our daily lives to ransom. However, even there, there are signs of hope for us embattled taxpayers.
This month, the town of Vallejo demonstrated not only that it was possible for a city to tear up its union contracts in bankruptcy, but that it was even easier for a city to do so than for a company. The precedent may matter.
Municipalities do not file for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection; they use Chapter 9, which has different terms and a much smaller body of legal precedent. Municipal bankruptcies are so rare that until the Vallejo ruling, it was not clear whether a city could get out of its union contracts in Chapter 9.
Unions representing Vallejo’s public employees tried to argue that state labor laws protected the contracts. But the federal judge handling the bankruptcy, Michael S. McManus, wrote that federal bankruptcy law trumped the state labor law. He also observed that Congress could have set tougher standards for municipalities voiding their labor contracts — it did so for companies. But such bills died in committee.
Posted in Government, Strategy & Scenarios |
No Comments »