Retract Too Early
reality
Retract too early/Make prop curly/You’ve gotta wait/For positive rate. Usually accompanied by a cartoon sketch of a bent propeller, posted on the bulletin board in pilots’ lounges.
I went long too early, clearly. I thought the values were compelling - and they were, and are. Fortunately, the drawdown is not serious and I added to my positions at even lower prices. Friday’s rally was encouraging, but we have had these before and they have quickly reversed. If that happens, I will hedge my positions. But the yields on the income trusts are just staggering, over 25%. I know energy prices are down, but these companies have hedged much of their output through 2009.
I even bought some bank shares on Friday - Scotiabank, one of the large Canadian banks and an old employer of mine, priced at half of their price a couple of months ago. A good company in what is now rated as the safest banking system in the world.
However, I am amazed at the lack of reaction from the public. Perhaps people are just stunned, or in denial. But everything seems business as usual. Fidelity Magellan, the mutual fund I use as a benchmark, is down 58% year-to-date. It is a large fund and should be pretty representative of the performance people are seeing from stocks and mutual funds. But there’s no sign of panic, really. I find this a little spooky. If my portfolio were down that much I would be having panic attacks, I think.
The messages that people need to take away are:
- Stocks may offer higher returns, but only at the price of much higher volatility and when bought right. You have to buy them at low valuations. Buying over-valued stocks is a recipe for trouble, even if your time horizon is long.
- Mutual funds and investment advisers who don’t provide some form of market timing are a joke, the fees they charge are just money down a rathole. A lot of money, too, in many cases. And even worse, thinking that they know anything you don’t gives a false sense of security.
- Wall Street is your enemy. It makes vast profits at your expense, not by being smart but by being in a position of information advantage. It knows its clients’ positions and intentions and exploits that knowledge for its own gain.
- Most advisers are incompetent. They drink the Wall Street and CNBC Kool-Aid and pass it on to their clients. In the event of my being unable to manage our investments for whatever reason, my instructions to my wife are to put the money into Hussman Funds. There’s a guy (John Hussman) who provides value for his fees.
Anyway, at some point the short-covering in the US dollar will be over, and the dollar will resume its decline, boosting energy and the other commodities (to say nothing of the Canadian dollar). And my portfolio, hopefully. But we’ll see. There’s no crystal ball, I just look at conditions and try to position accordingly.
Posted in * Portfolio changes, Asset Classes, Energy, Retirement, Rogues and Rascals, Stocks, Strategy & Scenarios |

November 23rd, 2008 at 12:45 pm
Hi Reality,
First, many thanks for sharing your thoughts.
I heard somewhere that nobody buys at the bottom and sells at the top; money is made in between. You will not be able to time the bottom other than by luck.
I have been getting more and more concerned about the chatter that keeps coming out of washington as well as leaders at other countries. They are announcing bailout after bailout with more borrowed or printed money. As money is debt, I take it to be the repudiation of existing debt.
Here are my somewhat disjointed thoughts:
- I am thinking more and more along the lines of a hurricane. The front side of the hurricane (deflation) smashes anyone who is leveraged. The back side of the hurricane (inflation) will smash anyone who is in paper currencies. Hard assets, if acquired at reasonable prices, may retain a reasonable amount of their value and should so well whenever we come out of this.
- The front of the hurricane is what we are living through. The debt destruction and deleveraging are producing deflation, crashing asset prices everywhere.
- The inflationary actions of the governments via borrowing and printing will produce the back end of the hurricane.
- Timing the switch right is going to be very difficult.
- Gold appears to be too expensive at current prices.
- Real estate is still too expensive in the area I live.
- Commodities may not have bottomed but they are no longer in a bubble. Can’t time the bottom though.
- Scale into positions as no one can time the bottom. Or wait for a lear indication that we have flipped the switch?
So what to do? Here are some ideas I am toying with
- Wait for real estate to become reasonable and then buy. This might take a year or two.
- If gold goes to the 4-500 range, it becomes interesting. I think the marginal cost of production for Gold is in the $400 range.
- For commodities, find the least cost producers and buy their shares. Make sure they are not overly leveraged compared to their industries. Buy only the larger players in the segment. Scale in as no one knows the bottom.
And last but not the least, keep your finger crossed :-) We are but straws in this hurricane.