There seem to be two parallel universes. One of them, let’s call it the Greenspan Universe after its leading prophet, is a financial Garden of Eden. The other, let’s name it in the same way the Prechter Universe, is more of a financial Armageddon.
Who lives in the Greenspan Universe? Well, nearly everyone, it seems. Certainly the financial press, the analysts, Wall Street, the government and most politicians of all stripes except for Ron Paul.
This universe has a strong global economic expansion underway, thanks to a Fed Chairman with an outsize ego and a talent for obfuscation, supported by miracles of structured finance and derivatives. Inflation is non-existent, job growth is strong, equity markets expect a continuing bull market despite historically high valuations, and debt markets are buoyant. The U.S. currency is strong because of hinted-at rate increases. U.S. consumers, having sustained the economy throughout the mini downturn, continue to spend and spend. Housing seems to throw off the talk of rate increases as starts and sales seem immune to any slowdown, rising to new records in sales.
Who lives in the Prechter Universe? Some of the greatest (and wealthiest) investors of all time; Warren Buffett, Sir John Templeton, Jim Rogers, Jeremy Grantham, Michael O’Higgins, Bill Fleckenstein, Ron Paul, Steve Roach. Austrian economists, the disciples of von Mises.
In this universe, the US is a nation living beyond its means, with a net international deficit position as of 3/31 to $5.2 trillion. In this other universe the reported inflation numbers in the U.S. are regarded as fictitious and “real†numbers in the 5-7% range are bandied about. For example, Sysco, the largest supplier to the hospitality industry, measures an 8% inflation rate in the cost of their product mix, which is a good proxy for household non-durables. The “measured” future rise in rates from the current 1.25% will never bring about the “neutral†position the Fed talks about, but simply aggravates an already serious inflation problem. Many argue that the expansion is flawed by malinvestment, particularly in residential real estate. A few see potential for a massive increase in bad loans, particularly in the consumer arena, which mught not be fun given that domestic banks now have over 75% of their assets in consumer-related loans, i.e. morgages, mortgage-backed securities, consumer direct and credit-card loans.
There is no communication between the two universes. Neither listens to the other.
The universes are superposed. In quantum physics, superpositions disappear when a measurement is made. This process is called decoherence. In financial market situations like this, the superposition disappears at the “Point of Realization” (POR).
Armageddon is a metaphor for the final conflict between good and evil. In this case, it is the final conflict between Keynesian economics and Austrian economics. One view or the other will have a POR.
Thanks for the original idea, and some of the text, to Edmund M. McCarthy, President and CEO of Financial Risk Management Advisors Company